If you are sizing up the work, start with our page on siding cost. Live nearby? See siding in Beaverdale. Doing your homework first? Read our guide on wood vs engineered wood siding.
Material comparison for the midwest
James Hardie is a fiber cement product made from sand, cement, and cellulose fibers. It is heavy and completely fire-resistant. This material does not rot or attract woodpeckers and insects, making it a favorite for homeowners in older Des Moines neighborhoods like Beaverdale or Sherman Hill.
LP SmartSide is engineered wood. It uses wood strands treated with zinc borate and bonded with water-resistant resins. It is lighter than fiber cement and comes in longer sixteen foot planks. This means fewer seams on the side of your house compared to Hardie's twelve foot lengths.
Handling Iowa weather and durability
Our local freeze-thaw cycles put immense pressure on exterior cladding. James Hardie is specifically engineered for northern climates to resist cracking and shrinking when temperatures drop in Waukee and Johnston. It handles moisture well but requires proper clearance from roofs and decks to prevent wicking.
LP SmartSide excels in impact resistance. In a heavy Iowa hail storm, the resin-bonded wood strands often bounce back better than fiber cement, which can crack under high-velocity impact. However, the cut edges of LP SmartSide must be primed and painted perfectly to prevent moisture from swelling the wood fibers over time.
Appearance and curb appeal differences
James Hardie offers a deep, authentic wood grain texture that mimics traditional cedar. It is often the top choice for historical renovations in neighborhoods where authenticity matters. The ColorPlus technology provides a baked-on finish that lasts for years without fading under the harsh summer sun.
LP SmartSide has a more uniform wood grain pattern. Because it comes in longer stretches, it looks very clean on large modern homes in suburbs like Ankeny or West Des Moines. You can buy it pre-finished or have it painted any custom color after we install it on your walls.
Cost and installation considerations
James Hardie generally costs more to install because it is heavy and requires specialized cutting tools. The labor is more intensive, as each plank must be handled carefully to avoid breakage. It is a long-term investment that typically carries a higher resale value for your property.
LP SmartSide is often more affordable because the installation goes faster. The lighter weight allows our crews to move quickly, and it can be cut with standard woodworking tools. This reduces the total labor hours billed to your project while still providing a professional, high-end look for your exterior.
Ask which material fits your home
Every house in the Des Moines metro area has different needs based on its age and exposure to the elements. We help you look at your specific lot to see if wind, sun, or shade makes one of these materials a better fit for your budget.
We provide clear breakdowns for both products so you can make an informed choice. Contact us today to walk through your options and see samples of both fiber cement and engineered wood in person. We serve all surrounding areas including Altoona, Clive, and Urbandale.